Sherlock Holmes Mafia - Game Over! Jester and Third Party Victory

Ok well I think there are a few shifty characters around but there a few who stand out to me. I think Joe and Harry are Mafia scum. I have a few sources. One is Joe himself, everytime I ask him he seems really troubled and finds it hard to keep pretending. Also the last time I asked he, his anger took hold and he pretty much threatened me that he wasn't mafia. Anyone who wasn't mafia wouldn't have done this. It was a very scummy move. I'm guessing Harry is also Mafia since he is acting very suspicious and shifty. So what do you guys think?

Lynch me if you wish Sam, I'll show as villager and you yourself will be lynched.

Night 2 has ended. Day 2 has begun. Submit your lynch votes by 14/02/2013

Writeup is on the OP.

Dead lines for votes is 19:00. Deadline for night actions is 20:00.

Vote Abdul.

Vote me? Haibo I tracked Hiney today as m role is a tracker and he had visited you. He is mafia killer. Lynch him not me and then you will see I am village for real. Otherwisewe will have few decent roles remaining as a bodyguard and an Inspector were killed. Trust me that I am a tracker and if you want confirmation ask Markham. He claimed to be an investigator and I tracked hi. |In the morning I told him who he tracked befor ehe had revealed it to anybody. He had tracked George but his outcome was that he was not mafia. George turned out to be mafia so now I think Andrew is bad cop. He is not mafia however so don't lynch him. Go for Harry or Joseph.

ANNOUNCEMENT

A woman has been shot early in the morning (during the Day phase). Once again, no shooter. Once again, no sound. Once again, revolver bullet. A curse was heard from an onlooker, this must be a last, or my skills are for naught.

Giver of good things was shot through the head.

He was:

Quote :

You are Mrs. Hudson

You are Sherlock Holmes's landlady.

Abilities:
Each day, you may submit a vote on who should be lynched.

If Sherlock is targeted successfully at night by a night kill, you die instead.
You know all of the people who targeted Sherlock in the night.

Win Condition:
You win when all evildoers have been eliminated.

.

Okay so haibo (claiming mrs Hudson) must have been targeted but miles was protecting haibo so he didn't die, the tall plae figure is presumably a reference to a certain person (possibly moriarty as he is notably tall, thin and he has white hair) and he must have been targeting sherlock's 'protectors' so that a highly influential role could be killed, that must mean that at the same time someone else (maybe a mafia plan to kill both protectors) attacked miles, clearly the idea is to get rid of sherlock's protectors so that he can be killed which would heavily help the mafia, this also leads to the idea that haibo will be the next to be killed. We know that sherlock was role blocked.

For those of you who watch Sherlock, who would a tall, thin, grey haired, ascetic looking man, who talks solemnly, be?

Justin Thyme wrote:

For those of you who watch Sherlock, who would a tall, thin, grey haired, ascetic looking man, who talks solemnly, be?

Pop on the chat (located on the main menu bar), pretty sure they'll be someone there who can answer your question

I have no idea myself xD

And now haibo has been killed leaving sherlock open for the mafia, this means haibo and miles must have been followed or someone knew of their protective roles, the killer was experienced enough to shoot haibo through the head and the same method as the kill on lusty was used so it is presumably the same person, the curse from the onlooker could be a detective getting the wrong person

Actually I think the curse may have been me as I was tracking Hiney during the night



This is proof that Hiney is changing his role he is now apparently a bodyguard.

Oops wrong screenshot. Well that one showed that Hiney knew a mafia member but didnt tell others. And how could he knpw/ He must be mafia

Here is the correct screenshot

And another to solidify my point

Justin Thyme wrote:

For those of you who watch Sherlock, who would a tall, thin, grey haired, ascetic looking man, who talks solemnly, be?

It might be the case that some things are based on the books.

tiger wrote:

Justin Thyme wrote:

For those of you who watch Sherlock, who would a tall, thin, grey haired, ascetic looking man, who talks solemnly, be?

It might be the case that some things are based on the books.

QUICK SOMEONE CLEVER READ THE BOOKS

Harry Collinge, Nick Cooper and Andrew Markham visited Sherlock on Night 2.

This was my final PM. Take it how you wish. Its pretty clear Harry and Nick are mafia. Go get em!

Giver of good things wrote:

Harry Collinge, Nick Cooper and Andrew Markham visited Sherlock on Night 2.

This was my final PM. Take it how you wish. Its pretty clear Harry and Nick are mafia. Go get em!

Right, that helps us a lot. Andrew is dead. Harry... I don't really know a lot on, but I'd be more convinced by Nick if I'm honest, as he's been really inactive this game - we only saw him on chat for the first time tonight.

Not completely sold, but for now, lynch lofds.

Giver of good things wrote:

Harry Collinge, Nick Cooper and Andrew Markham visited Sherlock on Night 2.

This was my final PM. Take it how you wish. Its pretty clear Harry and Nick are mafia. Go get em!

I did visit, but for a completely different reason to what people assume.

In yichen's post he says sherlock is nowhere to be seen the following morning. Seems he's been kidnapped by either colllinge or cooper, seeing as markam is dead so he can't have, and that mean's at least one of them is mafia. As for which, as far as I can tell, both of them have been keeping rather quiet, so maybe both of them are. I'm going with sam and voting for cooper(Yichen), seeing as I don't really know who to go for, and sam's more experienced than me.
(and Hiney stop picking on vanillas to take the blame off yourself. it's a pit pathetic, and also makes it really blatent too, though i'm not voting for him yet because he doesn't seem as powerful as at least one of the two i mentioned above, and it's more important to take out the powerful ones early on so we stand a better chance)
That's what I think of anyway. Get mad.

Lynch lofds

Strong evidence against him. If it's not him, choose the other guy.

Day 2 has Ended

Write up is in the OP.

Night 3 has begun, submit your night actions by 20:00 of tonight.

ANNOUNCEMENT

Justin Thyme has been sniped and killed (revolver bullet... yadda yadda). He is Inspector Hopkins (role on the OP).

Death Post:

I may have been killed because the description I asked about was Clunge's character, who turned out to be maf.

With my new powers I inspected Snowball, who is a mafioso and the golem.

So yeah, lynch away

haha, joe looks like a fat golem

Majority is probably 7... I think.